How to Win Back Past Applicants: A Guide for Recruiters

How to Win Back Past Applicants: A Guide for Recruiters

You’ve already paid for the click. The candidate applied. Maybe they even took a call. And then… they disappeared.

But here’s the good news: past applicants are often your best untapped source of future hires. They’re already familiar with your company, they showed interest once, and with the right approach, you can win them back.

If you're not actively re-engaging your existing applicant database, you're leaving money on the table—and probably increasing your cost per hire in the process. Here's how to do it right.

1. Build a Retargeting Strategy

Just because a candidate didn’t convert the first time doesn’t mean they’re gone for good. Retargeting helps bring them back by reminding them of your open roles while they browse the web, scroll social media, or check their email.

Tips for retargeting success:

• Upload your past applicant list to advertising platforms (Google, Meta, etc.) and serve them tailored job ads.
  
  
• Create ad variations that highlight different roles, benefits, locations, or perks they may not have noticed before.
  
  
• Use urgency messaging like “positions filling fast” or “reopening role near you.”
  
  

2. Launch an Email & SMS Drip Campaign

Most recruiters follow up once or twice and then move on. But a well-planned drip campaign can keep you top of mind until the candidate is ready to move.

What to include in your drip sequence:

• A “welcome back” message reminding them of your company and current openings.
  
  
• Personalized job alerts based on their previous preferences or location.
  
  
• Testimonials from current employees, updates to pay/benefits, or reminders about sign-on bonuses.
  
  
• A direct line to a recruiter (“Have questions? Text us anytime.”)
  
  

Make sure your messages are short, mobile-friendly, and spaced out over time. Not everyone is ready to make a move this week—but many will be soon.

3. Keep a Warm Pipeline

The strongest recruiting teams treat their applicant pool like a CRM—not just a pile of resumes. Past applicants should be categorized, scored, and revisited on a regular basis.

How to keep your pipeline warm:

• Tag applicants by status (qualified, needs follow-up, not ready, etc.)
  
  
• Schedule periodic check-ins with high-potential candidates.
  
  
• Share occasional updates via text or email—even if it’s just to say hello or let them know you’re still hiring.
  
  

When you treat candidates like people, not numbers, they remember that. And when they’re ready for a change, they’ll come back to you first.

How Advantage.Ai Can Help

At Advantage.Ai, we’ve spent a lot of time helping organizations across industries improve their recruitment outcomes—and we’ve seen firsthand how easily past applicants can slip through the cracks.

We’ve helped companies re-engage their databases using targeted retargeting ads, smart email and SMS drip campaigns, and pipeline management strategies that keep your best leads warm.

The best part? We handle the heavy lifting—strategy, setup, optimization—so your recruiting team can stay focused on hiring.

If you're tired of starting from scratch every time you need to fill a role, let us show you how to tap into the power of your existing leads and bring top talent back into the fold.

Final Thoughts

Your next great hire might already be in your system—you just need the right tools and strategy to reach them. With Advantage.Ai on your side, you can lower your cost per hire, speed up time-to-fill, and keep your recruiting engine running at full speed. Set up a demo with our team today!

‍